Understanding RSU Tax Withholding: Strategies to Manage Your Tax Liability on Restricted Stock Units

Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) are a common part of compensation packages, especially in the tech industry, where companies aim to attract and retain talented employees with forms of equity compensation. However, when it comes to RSUs, managing tax withholding is crucial to avoid unexpected tax bills and maximize your after-tax income. In this article, we’ll explore key tax concepts around RSUs and actionable strategies for handling RSU tax withholding effectively.

What are Restricted Stock Units (RSUs)?

A Restricted Stock Unit (RSU) is a form of deferred compensation where your employer promises to grant you shares of company stock at a future date once certain conditions are met, like staying with the company for a specified period or meeting performance goals. Unlike stock options, RSUs do not require you to buy shares; instead, they are granted to you as part of your compensation package.

RSUs are subject to a vesting schedule, often over several years, during which the shares remain restricted and are not fully yours. When the RSUs vest, however, you gain ownership, and the fair market value of the stock at the vesting date becomes part of your taxable income. This vesting date is when tax withholding obligations begin.

How RSUs are Taxed at Vesting

When RSUs vest, they are treated as ordinary income. Your employer will withhold a portion of your RSU income to cover federal income tax, Social Security, and Medicare taxes. The default withholding rate is typically 22% for income under $1 million, but if your total income puts you in a higher tax bracket, this may not cover your full tax liability.

Consider this example:

• Suppose your company grants you 500 RSUs, and they vest when the stock price is $100 per share. This gives you $50,000 in taxable income from the vested shares.
• At a 22% withholding rate, $11,000 will be withheld for federal taxes. However, if your overall income pushes you into the 32% tax bracket, you will actually owe $16,000 in taxes on the RSUs, meaning you’re short $5,000.

In such cases, it’s crucial to understand that your actual tax liability may exceed what your employer withholds, so you may need to plan to cover this difference.

Calculating Your RSU Tax Liability

A detailed calculation helps you anticipate your tax obligation more precisely and avoid underpayment. Here’s how to approach this:

1. Quick Calculation:
   • Multiply the fair market value of your vested shares by the number of shares to get your taxable income.
   • Multiply this amount by your marginal tax rate to estimate your federal income tax.
2. Detailed Calculation Example: Suppose your RSUs vest, giving you 300 shares at a share price of $80, resulting in $24,000 of taxable income. Here’s how you’d break down the tax owed:
   • Federal Income Tax: If you’re in the 24% tax bracket, your federal tax would be 24% of $24,000, or $5,760.
   • Social Security Tax: Social Security tax applies at 6.2% up to the annual wage cap. Assuming you haven’t reached this cap, Social Security tax on $24,000 would be $1,488.
   • Medicare Tax: Medicare tax is 1.45% on all wages, so the Medicare tax here would be $348.
   • State Income Tax: If your state income tax rate is 5%, you’d owe an additional $1,200.
   • This would result in a total tax of about $8,796, or 36.65% of the RSU income, far more than the 22% withholding rate.

    

    

   Action Step: You may want to adjust your tax withholding elsewhere or make an estimated tax payment to cover the shortfall, especially if your total income is significantly higher due to the RSUs.

Common Tax Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them

1. Under-withholding: Default withholding can lead to underpayment, especially for high earners. For instance, if your RSUs are worth $100,000, the standard withholding may cover only $22,000, but if you’re in the 37% tax bracket, you’ll owe $37,000, leaving a $15,000 gap.
   • Solution: Check with your payroll department to see if you can increase withholding on your regular income or set aside additional funds in a high-yield savings account to cover tax time.
2. Stock Price Volatility: The stock price can fluctuate between grant, vesting, and sale. If the stock price drops after vesting, you may pay taxes on a higher amount than you can later sell the shares for, creating a potential capital loss.
   • Example: If your RSUs vest when the stock price is $60, but it drops to $50 when you sell, you’ll have paid taxes on $60 per share but realized a lower sale price. To offset this, consider selling a portion immediately upon vesting and setting aside the cash to cover taxes, thus reducing your risk exposure to stock price changes.
3. Tax Timing Issues: RSUs often vest in a particular tax year when additional income (e.g., cash bonus) may push you into a higher bracket. This can increase your tax bill substantially when you file your tax return.
   • Actionable Strategy: If you know your RSUs will vest in a high-income year, consider deferring other sources of income to take a tax deduction or consult a tax advisor on strategies to offset the higher income with deductions or retirement contributions.

Managing Tax Liability When Selling RSU Shares

When you sell RSU shares, you’re subject to capital gains taxes based on how long you hold them after vesting. If you sell within a year, any gains are considered short-term and taxed at your ordinary income tax rate. After a year, they’re subject to long-term capital gains rates, which can be more favorable.

Example:

• Suppose your RSUs vest at a stock price of $80. If you sell immediately, there’s no capital gain, so you only owe tax on the ordinary income.
• If you hold for over a year and the stock price rises to $100, your $20 gain per share is taxed at long-term capital gains rates. This can lead to tax savings if you’re in a high-income bracket.

Action Step: Decide on a holding strategy based on your financial goals and tax situation. Holding for the long-term capital gains rate can be advantageous, but if the stock is volatile, you may choose to sell immediately to avoid risk.

RSU Tax Strategies for High-Income Tech Employees

1. Withhold More or Make Estimated Tax Payments: Many high-income tech employees find the default RSU withholding insufficient. To avoid a large tax bill, consider requesting a higher withholding on your salary or making quarterly estimated tax payments.
   • Example: If your total RSU value is expected to exceed $200,000, calculate your estimated tax using the 32-37% tax brackets. Making quarterly payments based on this higher rate can save you from a hefty April surprise.
2. Timing the Sale of Vested Shares: Timing your sale can have significant tax implications. Selling immediately upon vesting can help cover taxes owed, while holding for over a year may reduce taxes if the stock appreciates.
3. Offsetting RSU Income with Deductions: Contributions to retirement plans or Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) can reduce taxable income, partially offsetting your RSU tax impact.
   • Example: If your RSUs add $50,000 to your income, maxing out a 401(k) contribution (up to $22,500 in 2024) can reduce your taxable income, lowering your effective tax rate. Your tax rates will be impacted by both actions.

The Role of a Financial Advisor in RSU Tax Planning

A financial advisor can be invaluable in helping you navigate the complexities of RSU taxation. They can provide guidance on:

• Investment Advice: Advising on whether to hold or sell shares based on your financial goals, risk tolerance, and current market conditions.
• Tax Planning: Helping you structure your income to minimize tax liability, such as through estimated tax payments or state income tax planning if you’re in a high-tax state.
• Cash Flow Management: Assisting with strategies to cover tax withholding without disrupting other financial goals. RSU taxes don’t have to sneak up on you again.

For example, if your RSU vesting coincides with a major expense, an advisor can help ensure you have liquidity without needing to sell shares at an inopportune time. Advisors can also guide you on aligning your RSU strategy with a larger investment plan, helping you make the most of this equity compensation form.

Conclusion

Restricted Stock Units can be a valuable part of your compensation package, but they come with tax implications that require careful planning. Managing RSU tax withholding, understanding your potential tax liability, and developing a strategy for selling shares can help you maximize your after-tax income and reach your financial goals.

RSU tax withholding is complex, but by staying informed and working with a tax professional or financial advisor, you can avoid costly mistakes and make the most of your equity compensation. Whether you’re dealing with RSUs now or preparing for a future vesting date, proactive tax planning is essential to optimizing your financial strategy.

Disclaimer:

This website (the “Blog”) is published and provided for informational and entertainment purposes only.  The information in the Blog constitutes the Content Creator’s own opinions and it should not be regarded as a description of services provided by Arch Financial Planning, LLC or Cecil Staton, CFP® CSLP®.

The opinions expressed in the Blog are for general informational purposes only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual or on any specific security or investment product.  It is only intended to provide education about personal financial planning.  The views reflected in the commentary are subject to change at any time without notice.

Nothing on this Blog constitutes investment advice, performance data, or any recommendation that any security, portfolio of securities, investment product, transaction, or investment strategy is suitable for any specific person.  From reading this Blog we cannot assess anything about your personal circumstances, your finances, or your goals and objectives, all of which are unique to you, so any opinions or information contained on this Blog are just that – an opinion or information.  You should not use this Blog to make financial decisions and we highly recommended you seek professional advice from someone who is authorized to provide investment advice.